Assuming open water here, it's chartreuse. For the single preferred color for open water pike (as per your thread title), nothing else even comes close.
There are a couple other color combos that really rock based on different weather and water conditions, but that's not what you asked.
Guided lake trout trips at fossguide.com
Pro staff: Striker Ice, Big-Nasty Tackle, ION augers, Eskimo, Tuned Up Custom Rods, Vexilar.