Home | Ice Fishing Reports | HSOList Classifieds | HSOshow | Resorts,Guides,Boats | Ice Leaders | Business Services | Site Map | OutdoorProStore
@ the Leading Edge:
Search
Featured HSOList Classifieds
Browning Gold Shotgun and Puma Lever Action Rifle
Mud Buddy Mud Motor For Sale
Sky light for Ice fishing or hunting shack
Deer Hunters! Knife Sharpening!
Mint Condition 816 V Front ice house/camper
2007 Ice Castle Price Reduced SOLD
Single place snowmobile trailer
New Topics
track truck
by osakis cabin
09:27 PM
Native American Anglers
by GravelBar
08:24 PM
Recording your hunt
by Bambito
08:16 PM
Events For You to Enjoy!
On The Forums ...
Sons art project Les Kouba?
by mwal
St Cloud Fishing Reports
by Horseshoe_Don
2014 upland game pics
by CaptainMusky
What is wrong with these people?!
by Early Riser
Who can find something to complain about this?
by swamptiger
Favorite pheasant recipes
by Pherris
Hunting reports....
by FISHINGURU
05:28 AM
Cell phones - What are you packin'?
by JeremyCampbell
01:48 AM
Buck Chasing Does??
by tipup
01:14 AM
Humminbird Customer Service?
by RiverDewey
01:06 AM
Kids Carving Pumpkins
by JeremyCampbell
12:41 AM
Best fishing area in the cities??
by RiverDewey
11:31 PM
2014 Regs and buck harvest
by SmellEsox
11:30 PM
track truck
by osakis cabin
10:50 PM
Mn makes WSJ (politics) front page
by Bureaucrat
10:33 PM
FREE HSOList.com
Classifieds
Browning Gold Shotgun and Puma Lever Action Rifle
Mud Buddy Mud Motor For Sale
Sky light for Ice fishing or hunting shack
Forum Stats
61722 Members
233 Forums
303865 Topics
2630690 Posts
Share HotSpotOutdoors with family & your good friends.
Who's Online
40 registered Members, 801 Guests and YOU online now.

Become family and
share HSO.

"i'm having fun"
At the Leading Edge
"!!

Topic Options
Rate This Topic
Hop to:
#2403894 - 11/16/10 01:37 PM
Furnace vs Gas Fireplace
Bass N Spear Offline
HotSpotOutdoors Pro Staff

Registered: 08/24/06
Posts: 15538
Loc: Sartell, MN
I live in a townhome that was built 10 years ago, and im wondering if you all think its less expensive to run the furnace over the fireplace, or vis vera

Thanks

Take a Kid Spearing!!
Spearing Isn't A Sport, Its a Family Tradition!!!




HotSpotOutdoors.com Prostaff/Spearing Prostaff
Clam Outdoors!
bassnspear@yahoo
Top
#2404477 - 11/17/10 06:17 AM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: Bass N Spear]
Surface Tension Online   sonar

HotSpotOutdoors PR Administrator

Registered: 02/01/02
Posts: 17028
Loc: Twig, Mn
If this was a primary heat source then the fireplace won't come close.

Your furnace heat exchanger is sucking as much warm air out as it can.
Your burners are designed burn the gas efficiently with a clean blue flame

Your gas fireplace is letting a lot of heat escape out the flue. Depending on the fireplace it also isn't getting and efficient clean burn.

Lets say you keep every room cool except a room you gather in and spend most of your time.
Using the fireplace as additional heat there as opposed to heating the whole house to that higher temp with the furnace, then yes you'll save money. You would save more on zone management with the furnace though.

Lets be realistic about space heating, if your married it takes a special women that prefers a cold bedroom or bathroom. Someone is going to turn the heat up.

Frank DeLuca
HSO Administrator
Nils Master Sharpening Service
FM Sponsors
frankbdeluca@yahoo.com

Top
#2404494 - 11/17/10 06:38 AM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: Surface Tension]
BoxMN Offline
Sr HSO Family

Registered: 05/25/05
Posts: 4998
Loc: WBL, MN & Crosslake weekender
What we sometimes do at the cabin, which has gas furnace and fireplace, is run the fireplace in main room, with the furnace thermostat set to where we want it at nighttime, and just run the furnace fan ON so it redistributes the heat from fireplace all over. Then at night, we turn the fireplace off and go to bed. If the furnace needs to kick on it will, but it takes awhile for the room to cool down to where that needs to be. Keeping the fan on keeps the heat circulating so the other rooms aren't cold spots. Not sure how the extra electricity for furnace fan factors in though smile

Only way it gets cold is if we leave fireplace ON and furnace fan OFF and then close the bedroom doors. Main rooms get hot, and bedrooms get cold and furnace never kicks on due to temp at the thermostat being too high.

Good luck.

-Box
Top
#2405274 - 11/17/10 09:24 PM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: BoxMN]
Bass N Spear Offline
HotSpotOutdoors Pro Staff

Registered: 08/24/06
Posts: 15538
Loc: Sartell, MN
thanks all for the information!

Take a Kid Spearing!!
Spearing Isn't A Sport, Its a Family Tradition!!!




HotSpotOutdoors.com Prostaff/Spearing Prostaff
Clam Outdoors!
bassnspear@yahoo
Top
#2406424 - 11/18/10 11:00 PM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: BoxMN]
Archerysniper Offline
HotSpotOutdoors Pro Staff

Registered: 02/11/09
Posts: 4639
Loc: North Branch
Originally Posted By: BoxMN
What we sometimes do at the cabin, which has gas furnace and fireplace, is run the fireplace in main room, with the furnace thermostat set to where we want it at nighttime, and just run the furnace fan ON so it redistributes the heat from fireplace all over. Then at night, we turn the fireplace off and go to bed. If the furnace needs to kick on it will, but it takes awhile for the room to cool down to where that needs to be. Keeping the fan on keeps the heat circulating so the other rooms aren't cold spots. Not sure how the extra electricity for furnace fan factors in though smile

Only way it gets cold is if we leave fireplace ON and furnace fan OFF and then close the bedroom doors. Main rooms get hot, and bedrooms get cold and furnace never kicks on due to temp at the thermostat being too high.

Good luck.




This is how I'm heating my house now except I'm useing a corn stove and leaving it set at low,it's working great. It will really be put to the test around thanksgiving we got some good ice making weather moveing in. Just trying to save on buying more propane that stuff isn't getting any cheaper.

2010 HSO.com Turkey Contest WINNER
1st place 2013 carpfest
2013 HSO.com Turkey Contest WINNER

East Central MDAA President
Protecting our Heritage


"Run your decoys high, keep your spear on your shoulder,

and your foot off the rope." -unknown-
Top
#2409013 - 11/22/10 07:44 AM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: Archerysniper]
spearchucker Offline
Sr HSOList.com Family

Registered: 12/16/02
Posts: 1651
Loc: Van down by the river
Gas fireplace is nowhere near as efficient as a furnace (even an old one).
Top
#2409534 - 11/22/10 02:27 PM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: BoxMN]
LightningBG Offline
Sr HSO Family

Registered: 12/14/08
Posts: 4505
Loc: Lake Elmo, MN
Originally Posted By: BoxMN
What we sometimes do at the cabin, which has gas furnace and fireplace, is run the fireplace in main room, with the furnace thermostat set to where we want it at nighttime, and just run the furnace fan ON so it redistributes the heat from fireplace all over. Then at night, we turn the fireplace off and go to bed. If the furnace needs to kick on it will, but it takes awhile for the room to cool down to where that needs to be. Keeping the fan on keeps the heat circulating so the other rooms aren't cold spots. Not sure how the extra electricity for furnace fan factors in though smile


Having the heat from the fireplace distribute throughout the house/cabin defeats the purpose of not using the furnace. If you want the whole house warm, use the furnace. It is the most efficient producer of heat in the house. If you only need 1 room warm and are willing to let the others get cold, use the fireplace, because all of the heat is going into the one room.

"A fine is a tax for doing something bad, a tax is a fine for doing something good."
Top
#2411778 - 11/24/10 02:25 PM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: LightningBG]
BoxMN Offline
Sr HSO Family

Registered: 05/25/05
Posts: 4998
Loc: WBL, MN & Crosslake weekender
Hi LighningBG. Yep, I understand that and good info for heating purposes, but when we want the "look and feel" of the fireplace, it actually even gets too hot at times in the room even with the flame set fairly low. So we just do this when the fireplace is on and it gets too warm. To get heat into the place quick, or when we are not "enjoying the fire" we do use the furnace, as it is high efficiency anyway, and we have off peak wirsbo in the basement... but if we have the fireplace on anyway, might as well spread the "warmth" smile

Happy T-Day to everybody tomorrow!

-Box
Top
#2411827 - 11/24/10 03:10 PM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: BoxMN]
Surface Tension Online   sonar

HotSpotOutdoors PR Administrator

Registered: 02/01/02
Posts: 17028
Loc: Twig, Mn
A gas fireplace is a luxury the way I see it, I think most people feel that way
Its going to cost to use it when you want that look and feel. Nothing wrong with that.

Box, Happy Thanksgiving to you and everyone.

Frank DeLuca
HSO Administrator
Nils Master Sharpening Service
FM Sponsors
frankbdeluca@yahoo.com

Top
#2411908 - 11/24/10 04:28 PM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: Surface Tension]
harvey lee Offline
HSO Legacy Member

Registered: 12/01/05
Posts: 32156
Loc: SC MN
I had one put in our living room when we built the house. We leave the house at about 66 and then use the gas fireplace for the living room as we spend the majority of our time there.

We can sleep in a bedroom at 66 with no problems.

Happty T-Day and safe travels.

You may believe the grass is greener on the other side. If you take the time to water yours, it would be just as green.



Top
#2412003 - 11/24/10 06:20 PM
Re: Furnace vs Gas Fireplace [Re: harvey lee]
Bass N Spear Offline
HotSpotOutdoors Pro Staff

Registered: 08/24/06
Posts: 15538
Loc: Sartell, MN
how much does the gas fireplace cost when its running

Take a Kid Spearing!!
Spearing Isn't A Sport, Its a Family Tradition!!!




HotSpotOutdoors.com Prostaff/Spearing Prostaff
Clam Outdoors!
bassnspear@yahoo
Top
Use the Share Buttons below, If You Like this topic.
FishingMinnesota
HSO Business
Discover how HSO delivers outdoor marketing.
Guerrilla Tactics Unveiled - Pound this link to see for yourself.




We Thank the
Quality Business that
Help Us Have Fun